Central Park Carriage Drivers Sue NYC Over Ban Set for June 2028

Central Park's horse-drawn carriage drivers sued New York City after the mayor signed a ban due by June 2028. Here is what each side says.

Horse-drawn carriages lined up in a lush city park.
Photo: Luca Sullivan / Pexels

The union representing Central Park’s horse-drawn carriage drivers filed a federal lawsuit in Manhattan on Thursday, minutes after Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed a law that will end the rides. According to ABC News, the law is set to stop the carriages by June 2028.

For visitors, nothing changes yet. The rides, a long-running tourist draw in the park, can continue while the law winds down the industry and while the court case plays out.

What the city says

At a signing ceremony at City Hall, Mamdani praised the part horses played in the city’s growth. He said the animals should no longer pull tourists through a park that is always busy with joggers, cyclists and other people on foot. “Our city has changed and now it is time for our laws to change, too,” he said.

City lawmakers revived the push for a ban this year after an 18-year-old tourist from India died. According to ABC News, he jumped from a runaway carriage, in what appeared to be the first death in a carriage accident since the rides were introduced in the park.

The city has also promised a career transition plan for people who work in the industry. City Hall says it will be released next April and will include job training, educational pathways and stipends. A spokesperson for the city’s law department said the office is reviewing the lawsuit.

What the drivers say

The Transport Workers Union, which represents the drivers, argues that the law is unconstitutional and that the city broke local legal procedures when it passed the measure. The suit names the mayor and other city officials as defendants.

The union also says the city is taking away its members’ livelihoods. The complaint says the city’s approach comes down to twelve words: “immediately cripple the owners, ignore property interests and contracts, and maybe compensate.”

Union head John Samuelsen said that, despite the mayor’s good intentions, the protections he described recently should have been written into the legislation itself. Drivers say their future remains uncertain.

Why it matters for visitors

The carriages have been a fixture of visits to Central Park for years, and the fight over them is old. Animal welfare activists have argued that the rides amount to cruelty, while supporters call them a romantic link to the city’s past.

The city has added safety rules over the years in response to incidents in which horses collapsed or were startled and ran into cars or other objects. Those rules include veterinary checkups, vacation time for the horses and a retirement age.

A federal judge could now decide whether the June 2028 deadline holds. Until a ruling or the end date, travelers planning a carriage ride should check the current status before they go, since the outcome of the case is not known.

Source: ABC News